Captiva Island FL Real Estate Listings
Active MLS listings on Captiva Island — one of Florida's most private and sought-after barrier islands. Updated daily.
Captiva Island sits at the northern tip of Sanibel Island and is accessible only by bridge or boat, making it one of the most private and exclusive real estate markets in Southwest Florida. The island has no traffic lights, no chain restaurants, and no high-rise development — by design. Properties range from Gulf-front single-family homes to bayside cottages, with the majority of the market sitting between $1.5M and $8M. Hurricane Ian caused significant damage to both Sanibel and Captiva in 2022, and the recovery on Captiva has been slower given its more limited infrastructure. Insurance costs are among the highest in SWFL — buyers must obtain quotes before any offer.
- One of Florida's most exclusive islands
- No high-rise development
- Gulf-front and bayside lots
- Significant post-Ian inventory opportunity
760 Sextant Dr 722, Sanibel, Florida 33957
760 Sextant DR, 33957, Sanibel, MARINER POINTE CONDOResidential - Low Rise (1-3)
527 E Gulf Dr # 204, Sanibel, Florida 33957
527 E Gulf DR, 33957, Sanibel, GULF BEACH CONDOResidential - Low Rise (1-3)
760 Sextant Dr # 612, Sanibel Fl 33957
760 Sextant DR, 33957, Sanibel, MARINER POINTE CONDOResidential - Low Rise (1-3)
3313 W Gulf Dr 102, Sanibel, Florida 33957
3313 W Gulf DR, 33957, SanibelResidential - Low Rise (1-3)
1785 Middle Gulf Dr A103, Sanibel, Florida 33957
1785 Middle Gulf DR, 33957, Sanibel, SANDDOLLAR CONDOResidential - Low Rise (1-3)
918 Limpet Dr, Sanibel, Florida 33957
918 Limpet DR, 33957, Sanibel, SHELL HARBORResidential - Single Family Residence
2737 W Gulf Dr 225, Sanibel, Florida 33957
2737 W Gulf DR, 33957, Sanibel, SAND POINTEResidential - Low Rise (1-3)
1286 Par View Dr, Sanibel, Florida 33957
1286 Par View DR, 33957, Sanibel, BEACHVIEW COUNTRY CLUB ESTATESResidential - Single Family Residence
1% Total Commission On The Sale Of Your Home
1
Photo Enhancement
Professional editing brings every photo to life — balanced exposure, corrected color, bright skies, and rich, true-to-life detail, finished to a magazine standard.
2
Drone Photography
Aerial photography captures the lot, the rooflines, the water or golf views, and the surrounding neighborhood — often the deciding factor for waterfront and golf course properties.
3
Virtual Staging
Empty rooms are digitally furnished with tasteful, realistic furniture, helping buyers picture themselves in the space at a fraction of the cost of physical staging.
4
3D Virtual Tours
Immersive walkthroughs let buyers explore every room on their own time, from anywhere in the country — often the tool that decides an out-of-state purchase.
5
Cinematic Storytelling
Professionally produced video tours walk buyers through the home and the lifestyle around it — the content that gets shared, saved, and remembered.
6
Luxury Presentation
Refined layouts, premium imagery, and placement built to stand out. For luxury and estate properties we expand into print exposure and dedicated campaigns.
SELLING?
We Are ONE % Commission.
Realty of Naples FL
When you list at 1% commission with Realty of Naples, Scott handles your sale personally — not a call center, not a junior agent. 35 years of Naples negotiation experience working every offer to your bottom line.
The valuation is free, the conversation is free, and there's zero obligation.
1401 Middle Gulf Dr 305r, Sanibel, Florida 33957
1401 Middle Gulf DR, 33957, Sanibel, SUNDIAL OF SANIBELResidential - Mid Rise (4-7)
760 Sextant Dr 811, Sanibel, Florida 33957
760 Sextant DR, 33957, Sanibel, MARINER POINTE CONDOResidential - Low Rise (1-3)
1314 Tahiti Dr, Sanibel, Florida 33957
1314 Tahiti DR, 33957, Sanibel, TRADEWINDSResidential - Single Family Residence
5657 Baltusrol Ct # 2b, Sanibel Fl 33957
5657 Baltusrol CT, 33957, Sanibel, THE SANCTUARYResidential - Low Rise (1-3)
2539 Coconut Dr, Sanibel, Florida 33957
2539 Coconut DR, 33957, Sanibel, DEL SEGAResidential - Single Family Residence
1340 Middle Gulf Dr 7a, Sanibel, Florida 33957
1340 Middle Gulf DR, 33957, Sanibel, SUNSET SOUTH CONDOResidential - Mid Rise (4-7)
241 Violet Dr, Sanibel, Florida 33957
241 Violet DR, 33957, Sanibel, LONG ACRE LAKEResidential - Single Family Residence
827 E Gulf Dr F-7, Sanibel, Florida 33957
827 E Gulf DR, 33957, Sanibel, SANIBEL ARMS WEST CONDOResidential - Low Rise (1-3)
503 E Gulf Dr # A, Sanibel Fl 33957
503 E Gulf DR, 33957, Sanibel, KINZIE ISLANDResidential - Low Rise (1-3)
What buyers need to know before purchasing in Captiva Island
About the Author
Scott Cowan Broker / Owner — Realty of Naples FL Scott Cowan is the broker and owner of Realty of Naples FL — a licensed real estate brokerage with offices in Florida, New Jersey, and New York. With nearly 35 years of experience and over $100,000,000 in closed transactions, Scott brings a depth of market knowledge that few Naples agents can match.