3951 Arlington St, Fort Myers, Florida 33901
Overview
- 2026044357
- Single Family Residence, Residential
- 3
- 2
- 1438 Sqft
- 0.224 Acres
- 1957
Description
Built in 1957 and thoughtfully renovated in 2023, 3951 Arlington Street is where true mid-century modern character meets the upgrades today’s buyers want. The low, sweeping roofline and one-of-a-kind windows make this one of the most distinctive homes in Palm Lee Park, filling the home with natural light throughout the day. The 2023 renovation focused on what matters most in Florida: a new roof, new AC, electrical and plumbing upgrades, new doors, and select windows replaced with impact-rated windows. Inside, the open kitchen with new countertops and custom cabinetry flows into the living and dining areas, finished with fresh paint, new lighting and high-quality floating luxury vinyl plank floors. Both bathrooms were fully renovated. True to its roots, the home keeps its original terrazzo floors, on full display in the den. That spacious flex room is currently used as an art studio and works just as well as a playroom, office, gym or guest space. Step outside and you’ll see how much care the owners have poured into every inch of this property. Since 2023, they’ve transformed the yard into a series of outdoor living spaces. Multiple paver patios and lounge areas are spread across the oversized lot, so there’s always a place for a quiet morning coffee, a deep breath in the shade, or an evening with friends. Stepping-stone paths wind through lush tropical plantings, and through a private gate you’ll find a separate garden with raised beds and drip irrigation, ready for vegetables, herbs and flowers. Out front, agave, cactus and succulents are set in decorative rock with landscape lighting. The look is striking day or night, and it’s drought-tolerant and easy on the water bill. This is a yard built with love, and it shows. A long covered carport and extra-wide driveway leave room for multiple cars and a golf cart, and the oversized lot offers room to add a pool (buyer to verify with the City of Fort Myers). Fiber internet is already installed. The home sits in Flood Zone X, where flood insurance is not required by lenders. Then there’s the location. Palm Lee Park sits in the heart of Fort Myers, just off the McGregor Corridor, the city’s most beautiful drive, lined with royal palms and historic homes. You’re minutes from the Caloosahatchee River for sunset walks, McGregor Cafe for a leisurely breakfast, the Fort Myers Country Club golf course, and the newly reopened Edison Tavern for dinner and drinks after its two-year renovation. Homes with this much character are rarely this updated. Come see it in person.
What Will You Pay to Insure This Property?
Annual insurance estimates for this ZIP code, property type, and price tier. SWFL-specific breakdown.
SELLING?
We Are ONE % Commission.
Realty of Naples FL
When you list at 1% commission with Realty of Naples, Scott handles your sale personally — not a call center, not a junior agent. 35 years of Naples negotiation experience working every offer to your bottom line.
The valuation is free, the conversation is free, and there's zero obligation. The only thing you risk by reaching out is finding out how much more than 1% commission you've been paying.
635 Wedge Dr, Naples, Florida 34103
635 Wedge DR, 34103, Naples, MOORINGSResidential - Single Family Residence
901 Egrets Run 202, Naples, Florida 34108
901 Egrets RUN, 34108, Naples, PELICAN MARSHResidential - Low Rise (1-3)
499 16th Ave S, Naples, Florida 34102
499 16th S AVE, 34102, Naples, AQUALANE SHORESResidential - Single Family Residence
What Does the HOA Actually Cost — and Cover?
Your true monthly payment goes well beyond the mortgage. Here's the full picture including HOA, taxes, and insurance.
Estimated Annual Property Tax — This Property
Based on Collier County millage rates and Florida exemption rules.
Around this property
How Far Is Everything from This Property?
Real drive times calculated from this address — not straight-line distance.
What Will This Home Actually Cost Over 5 & 10 Years?
Beyond the mortgage — taxes, insurance, HOA, maintenance, and projected equity. Pre-filled from this listing.
SELLING?
We Are ONE % Commission.
Realty of Naples FL
When you list at 1% commission with Realty of Naples, Scott handles your sale personally — not a call center, not a junior agent. 35 years of Naples negotiation experience working every offer to your bottom line.
The valuation is free, the conversation is free, and there's zero obligation. The only thing you risk by reaching out is finding out how much more than 1% commission you've been paying.
1% Total Commission On The Sale Of Your Home
Everything a full-service brokerage does to make your home stand out — for a 1% commission.
1
Photo Enhancement
Professional editing brings every photo to life — balanced exposure, corrected color, bright skies, and rich, true-to-life detail, finished to a magazine standard. Those first images decide whether a buyer clicks through or scrolls past. We make sure yours stop the scroll.
2
Drone Photography
Aerial photography captures the lot, the rooflines, the water or golf views, and the surrounding neighborhood. For waterfront, golf course, and acreage properties, drone imagery is often the deciding factor — showcasing proximity to the Gulf, canal access, or a private setting in a single frame.
3
Virtual Staging
Empty rooms are digitally furnished with tasteful, realistic furniture and decor, helping buyers picture themselves in the space. Staged homes consistently sell faster and for more, and virtual staging delivers that advantage at a fraction of the cost of physical staging. We tailor each room to the buyer most likely to purchase.
4
3D Virtual Tours
Immersive, interactive walkthroughs let buyers explore every room on their own time, from anywhere in the country. With a true sense of layout, flow, and scale, a 3D tour pre-qualifies interest. For our many Northeast clients moving to Southwest Florida, it's often the tool that lets them decide on a home they've never set foot in.
5
Cinematic Storytelling
Professionally produced video tours walk buyers through the home and the lifestyle around it. We craft each video as a story — pacing the reveal of key spaces, highlighting the features buyers care about most, and capturing the feel of the home. This is the content that gets shared, saved, and remembered, extending your listing's reach far beyond the MLS.
6
Luxury Presentation
Your home is presented with the polish high-end buyers expect — refined layouts, premium imagery, and placement built to stand out. From the headline copy to the order of the photos, every detail is intentional, designed to communicate value and justify your asking price. For luxury and estate properties we expand into print exposure, magazine features, and dedicated campaigns.
Who Lives Here — and What Has the Market Done?
Demographics and 5-year price trends for this area. Key data for buyers relocating from the Northeast.
Days on Market & Price History
Listing activity for this property.
Schools Serving This Property
Public school assignments for this address based on ZIP code boundaries.
Price Per Sq Ft — How Does This Home Compare?
Flood Risk Assessment — This Property
Hurricane Risk Assessment — This Property
Historical storm track data and risk scoring for this ZIP code.
Estimate Your Monthly Payment
Pre-filled with data from this listing. Adjust any field.
Interested in this property?
Realty of Naples represents buyers and sellers across Southwest Florida at 1% commission. Whether you want to schedule a showing or list your own home, our team saves you tens of thousands compared to a traditional brokerage.
4393 Sonoma Oaks Cir, Naples, Florida 34119
- $510,000
- Beds: 3
- Baths: 3
- Garages: 2
- Townhouse, Residential
8494 Karina Ct, Naples, Florida 34114
- $529,000
- Beds: 2
- Baths: 2
- Garages: 2
- 0.14 Acres
- Villa Attached, Residential
Details
-
Property ID 2026044357
-
Price $429,500
-
Property Size 1438 Sqft
-
Land Area 0.224 Acres
-
Bedrooms 3
-
Bathrooms 2
-
Year Built 1957
-
Property Status Pending, For Sale
-
Property Type Single Family Residence, Residential
Additional details
-
Roof Shingle
-
Cooling Ceiling Fan(s), Central Electric
-
Heating Central Electric
-
Flooring Laminate, Terrazzo
-
County Lee
-
Property Type Residential
-
Parking Covered, Paved, Attached Carport
-
Waterfront None
-
Architectural Style Ranch, Single Family
- Scott Cowan
